What three decades of talks produced
The first Conference of the Parties (COP) met in Berlin in 1995, with 117 parties attending. It agreed the "Berlin Mandate" to negotiate stronger commitments, which led two years later to the Kyoto Protocol. Kyoto required developed countries to cut emissions by an average of 5% below 1990 levels and placed no obligations on developing countries such as China and India.
The next breakthrough took 18 years. Copenhagen in 2009 produced a pledge of $100 billion a year by 2020 but no successor to Kyoto. Paris in 2015 brought 196 parties into one agreement to hold warming "well below 2°C" and pursue 1.5°C, with each country setting its own target and no enforcement. Later COPs filled in the rules, created a loss and damage fund and, at Dubai in 2023, called for "transitioning away from fossil fuels". Glasgow's "phasedown" of coal, in place of "phase-out", came from an Indian proposal in the closing plenary.
CFR - Carbon Brief (COP26) - (COP28) - (COP29) - (COP30) - C2ES
Milestones, COP1 To COP32
| 1995 Berlin | Berlin Mandate to negotiate binding cuts |
| 1997 Kyoto | Kyoto Protocol: rich nations cut 5% |
| 2007 Bali | "Loss and damage" in a text |
| 2009 Copenhagen | $100bn a year pledged |
| 2010 Cancun | Below 2°C goal; Green Climate Fund |
| 2013 Warsaw | Loss and damage mechanism, no money |
| 2015 Paris | Paris Agreement, 1.5°C aim |
| 2021 Glasgow | Coal "phasedown"; India net zero 2070 |
| 2022 Sharm | Loss and damage fund agreed |
| 2023 Dubai | "Transition away" from fossil fuels |
| 2024 Baku | $300bn a year by 2035 |
| 2025 Belem | No fossil fuel text |
| 2026 Antalya | Under way |
| 2027 Addis | Ethiopia hosts COP32 |
About a degree taken off the projected warming, and a coal pipeline cut by 70%
Measured against where the world was heading, the process has moved the forecast. Climate Action Tracker estimated in 2015 that the policies then in place pointed to about 3.6°C of warming by 2100. Its November 2025 update put current policies at about 2.6°C, a figure it says has been "virtually unchanged" since 2021. UNEP's projections show a similar fall (chart). "That means Paris has already reduced future risks for people and ecosystems," Bill Hare of Climate Analytics said in December 2025.
Coal plans have shrunk. Coal capacity in planning fell from 1,179 gigawatts (GW) in 2015 to 355 GW in 2024, a 70% drop, according to Global Energy Monitor data analysed by Carbon Brief, as 58 countries cut or scrapped plans. The world added a record 692 GW of renewable capacity in 2025, IRENA says. A 2020 study in Nature Climate Change linked climate laws in 133 countries to emissions about 5.9 billion tonnes a year lower in 2016 than they would otherwise have been. The $100 billion goal was met in 2022, at $115.9 billion, two years late; about 69% of the public money was loans.
Al Jazeera - Down To Earth (UNEP) - Climate Home - Carbon Brief (coal) - SolarQuarter (IRENA) - Eskander and Fankhauser - Net Zero Tracker - Carbon Brief ($100bn)
Projected warming by 2100, by assessment (°C)
Current-policy projections except the last row. Sources: Climate Action Tracker via Al Jazeera - UNEP via Down To Earth
Emissions are higher, money is late, and coal plants are still being built
The process was set up to stop the rise in greenhouse gases, and that has not happened yet. Fossil carbon dioxide emissions were 23.6 billion tonnes in 1995 and 39.0 billion tonnes in 2025, according to Global Carbon Budget data published by Our World in Data. The Global Carbon Budget released on November 10 projects a fall of about 0.4% in 2026, to 38.2 billion tonnes, the first fall since the pandemic, driven mainly by lower oil use after the Iran conflict. The carbon budget left for 1.5°C is 150 billion tonnes from 2027, less than four years of current emissions.
The world commissioned 97.4 GW of new coal power in 2025, the second-highest year on record, most of it in China, Global Energy Monitor says. IRENA says the tripling goal for renewables is off track: it needs about 1.2 terawatts a year from 2026 to 2030. The loss and damage fund had $790 million pledged but $397 million paid in at the time of COP30, and its first $250 million round faces $2 billion to $3 billion of requests. Decisions need consensus, so a single group can keep fossil fuels out of a text, as happened at Belem.
Our World in Data - Carbon Brief (GCB 2026) - Global Energy Monitor - Argus (IRENA) - Eco-Business
World fossil CO2 emissions, billion tonnes
Source: Global Carbon Budget 2026 via Our World in Data
Do the summits justify their size?
The first ten COPs drew about 5,000 people each on average, Carbon Brief's analysis of UN lists shows. Dubai had 83,884 people in person, and Antalya has 92,934 registered so far. Counts by the Kick Big Polluters Out coalition found 503 fossil fuel lobbyists at Glasgow, 2,456 at Dubai and 1,602 at Belem, where they were one in 25 participants. A carbon management plan by the engineering firm Arup estimated Glasgow's footprint at about 102,500 tonnes of CO2 equivalent, with about 60% from international flights.
Critics say the size has outgrown the purpose. In 2021 Greta Thunberg mocked leaders' promises as "blah, blah, blah". A Club of Rome letter in November 2024, signed by 22 people including Ban Ki-moon, Christiana Figueres and Johan Rockstrom, said the process's "current structure simply cannot deliver the change at exponential speed and scale". It called for rules on who can host, disclosure of lobbying, and smaller, more frequent meetings.
Defenders say the summit is one part of a larger system. "No, the Paris Agreement has not failed," Figueres said in January 2025, calling the COP process "frankly, a small part of the reality". On reform, UN climate chief Simon Stiell said in July: "it is time for that discussion to take place".
Carbon Brief - Down To Earth - The Wire - CNBC - Dawn (AFP) - Eco-Business - Mongabay - Down To Earth
People registered at selected COPs, thousands
In person; *provisional. Source: Carbon Brief analyses of UNFCCC lists
More success in direction than in delivery
On the evidence above, the COP process has changed the direction of policy more than the level of emissions. Its measurable gains are in forecasts, plans and institutions: about a degree off projected warming since 2015, a coal pipeline 70% smaller, a finance goal met late, and a fund for losses. Its shortfall is in delivery: emissions 66% above 1995, less than four years of the 1.5°C budget left, and finance pledges falling. The charge of summit tourism has a factual basis in attendance and in lobbyist numbers. The reforms now proposed, smaller delegations, rules for hosts, lobbying disclosure and less frequent meetings, deal with size. None of them changes the consensus rule that lets one group block a text. AI-synthesised analysis from the sources on this page.
From no obligations under Kyoto to a 2070 net zero goal
At Glasgow in 2021 Narendra Modi announced five goals, including 500 GW of non-fossil capacity by 2030 and net zero by 2070. India's 2022 plan promised a 45% cut in emissions intensity from 2005 levels by 2030 and about 50% non-fossil power capacity. It reached 50.1% on June 30, 2025, five years early, though coal still supplied 69% of electricity generated in January. Its 2035 plan targets a 47% intensity cut and about 60% non-fossil capacity; Climate Action Tracker says the intensity goal "will not bring any real emission reductions". Per person, its fossil CO2 emissions were 2.19 tonnes in 2025 against a world average of 4.74. India withdrew its bid to host COP33 in April.
Down To Earth - Carbon Brief - Scroll - (COP33) - Our World in Data

