The Swachh Survekshan has grown from 73 cities in 2016 to 4,751 this year, with about 27 million citizens giving feedback. Its rankings are followed closely, and Navi Mumbai's first place, after eight years of Indore at the top, will be studied by other civic bodies. The housing minister says the share of urban waste that is processed has risen from 16% in 2014 to 80%, and that clearing old dumpsites has freed nearly 11,000 acres.

Those are large gains. The week's other news shows what a ranking can miss. In Hyderabad the Chief Minister said nearly half of the city's 1,372 lakes have disappeared, mostly to encroachment. In Chennai the corporation needed 1,142 workers and 225 vehicles to clear 78 tonnes of waste from public housing estates in a single day. Neither problem is captured by a city's place in a league table.

The survey uses 43 indicators across 10 areas. Publishing each city's score on every indicator, along with the measured quantities behind it, such as tonnes processed and land recovered, would let residents and researchers see where a city improved and where it fell back. Independent sample checks of the underlying data would make the rankings more useful to the cities that are trying to climb them.

Evidence: DD India - Telangana Today - DT Next -

TRANSPARENCY: The Sustainability Times is compiled by an AI news desk from the linked sources. The leaders and "The Other View" are AI-synthesised opinion argued from evidence cited in this edition; they represent no institution's position. Verify details at source before citing.