ANTALYA: The technical half of the COP31 climate talks in Antalya ended at 12:48 am on Sunday, November 15, amid "widespread disappointment with the lack of progress on many issues", according to the Earth Negotiations Bulletin (ENB), which reports on the talks each day. Most items were sent unresolved to ministers for the second week. They include the mitigation work programme, indicators for the Global Goal on Adaptation, carbon market rules, the just transition work programme and all guidance to the climate funds. Talks on agriculture failed to reach an outcome, and the subject returns in 2027.
The conference opened on November 9 only after talks on the agenda ran into the early hours. To avoid an open fight, the presidency left out two items proposed by African countries, on tripling adaptation finance and on a dialogue on trade and climate change. The Arab Group objected to any reference in the outcome to the voluntary roadmaps on moving away from fossil fuels and on ending deforestation that Brazil's COP30 presidency produced after Belem. On November 14 the group said it "would not accept any top-down global targets or targets addressing specific sectors or energy sources".
Fossil fuels. There is no negotiating item on fossil fuels. COP30 President Andre Correa do Lago presented the roadmap at the opening. Climate Home News reports that it is a 182-page voluntary document with a three-stage timetable to 2033, and that it advises countries to adopt national transition plans by 2028. European and small island states may try to cite it in the summit's cover decision. At the leaders' summit on November 11, UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres called for a windfall tax on fossil fuel profits. "Fossil fuels must go the way of the dinosaurs," he said. "The dinosaurs did not have a lobby. But fossil fuels do."
Finance. Money is the main fault line. A Carbon Brief analysis published on November 11 found that new public climate finance pledges for developing countries have fallen by about 71%, to about $11.7 billion a year from an average of about $40 billion. The United States is giving no official climate finance, and British and US cuts take $5.1 billion out of the Green Climate Fund in a single year, ENB reported. "Any conversation on new fresh money is dead in the water," said Wopke Hoekstra, the EU's climate commissioner. Countries still disagree on whether the goal of $100 billion a year was ever met. The EU, Japan, Canada and others want it recorded as met for 2022 to 2024; the African Group, the Arab Group and like-minded developing countries say it was not. Under the COP29 deal, developed countries must provide at least $300 billion a year by 2035, within a wider goal of $1.3 trillion a year from all sources.
Ambition. The UN's synthesis of national climate plans, reported by Climate Home News, finds that the 154 plans submitted so far would cut emissions about 6% below 2019 levels by 2035. The IPCC benchmark for 1.5°C is a cut of about 60%. The plans point to 2.1°C to 3.2°C of warming by 2100, depending on action after 2035. Several participants told ENB on the first day that "this is the first COP where we admit the world will exceed 1.5°C." In a science text, Russia, India and the Arab Group proposed deleting a figure of 1.47°C, plus or minus 0.13°C, for this year's global temperature.
Adaptation and losses. UNEP's Adaptation Gap Report, released on November 4, puts developing countries' adaptation needs at about $305 billion a year by 2035. Tripling adaptation finance, as agreed at Belem, would cover only 20% to 29% of that. Countries agreed in principle on a two-tier structure for the new just transition mechanism, but not on how to fund it. The loss and damage fund has provisionally set aside $21.6 million for Nepal after its floods, against recovery needs of $4.77 billion, Down To Earth reported.
The crowd. COP31 has 92,934 people registered in person, provisionally the most at any COP, according to a Carbon Brief analysis of UN lists. They include 18,812 party delegates and 14,285 guests of the host country. Health Policy Watch counted more than 70 leaders at the leaders' summit. Xi Jinping, Narendra Modi, Emmanuel Macron and Friedrich Merz did not attend, and the United States sent no delegation for a second year. "It is a disgrace that only one G7 head of state and a handful of G20 leaders are attending the summit," said Mohamed Adow of Power Shift Africa. Transparency International found 63 fossil fuel-linked delegates in nine EU national delegations.
Week two. The Environmental Integrity Group, which includes Switzerland, has proposed capping delegation sizes and holding a COP every two or three years. Russia, the Arab Group, the African Group, like-minded developing countries and Argentina opposed putting any reform of the UN process in the cover decision. Ministers take over on Monday. The high-level segment runs from November 17 to 19, and closing plenaries are due on Friday, November 20.
ENB 902 - 903 - 904 - 905 - 906 - 907 - Carbon Brief (finance) - Carbon Brief (delegates) - Climate Home News - Climate Home (NDCs) - Health Policy Watch - Down To Earth - The Week - Transparency International
Local governments have had a seat since Berlin
Local governments formed their own constituency in the talks at Berlin in 1995, with ICLEI as focal point. The Paris Agreement recognised the role of local and subnational governments, and in 2023 Dubai launched CHAMP, under which countries promise to work with cities on their national plans; 77 countries and the EU have now joined. Subnational net zero targets cover 2.55 billion people, up from 497 million in 2020. This year Antalya held the first leaders-level dialogue on cities at a COP.
COP31 In Numbers
Sources: Carbon Brief - Climate Home News
New public climate finance pledges for developing countries, $ billion a year
Fall of about 71%. Source: Carbon Brief analysis, Nov 11
Where The Talks Stand
| Cover decision | No agreed text; presidency consultations continue |
| Fossil fuels | No agenda item; Arab Group rejects sector or energy targets |
| Finance | Work programme text being drafted; scope of Article 9 disputed |
| Adaptation | 59 indicators; taskforce make-up disputed; sent to ministers |
| Just transition | Two-tier mechanism broadly agreed; funding open |
| Carbon markets | Article 6.2 fees and 6.8 sent on in brackets |
| Loss and damage | Guidance to fund disputed; revised text due |
| Agriculture | No outcome; returns in 2027 |
| UN process reform | Split on including it in the cover decision |
Source: ENB 907, November 16
India At COP31
India's opening statement on November 10 was given by Narendra Bhooshan, secretary at the environment ministry. He urged developed countries to "fulfil their climate finance obligations under the Paris Agreement", stressing Article 9.1 and common but differentiated responsibilities, Down To Earth reported. Before the summit, Environment Minister Bhupender Yadav said: "On CBAM, we will stand by our position," referring to the EU's carbon border tax.
In the rooms, India opposed just transition language on food systems and, with Saudi Arabia and Russia, resisted a timeline for IPCC reports to feed the 2028 global stocktake. In week two Yadav co-chairs the ministerial talks on mitigation with Germany's Carsten Schneider. Climate Action Tracker says India's 2035 plan allows emissions to rise to 6.3 billion tonnes, almost 64% above 2023. India withdrew its bid to host COP33 in April.
Down To Earth - Euronews - Climate Home - ENB 905, 907
Ministers In Charge, Week Two
| Mitigation | Carsten Schneider (Germany), Bhupender Yadav (India) |
| Finance | Monique Barbut (France), Robert Borje (Philippines) |
| Adaptation | Jiwoh Abdulai (Sierra Leone), Miatta Fahnbulleh (UK) |
| Just transition | Alicia Barcena (Mexico), Krzysztof Bolesta (Poland) |
| Ocean | Julie Dabrusin (Canada), Steven Victor (Palau) |
Heard In Antalya
"We are doing things differently at this COP." Simon Stiell, UN climate chief.
"Every new oil well drilled, every piece of coal extracted, is a threat to my country's future." Hilda Heine, President of the Marshall Islands.
"Developing countries pay nearly $1 trillion in interest on public debt." Abiy Ahmed, Prime Minister of Ethiopia, host of COP32.
"This document does not need streamlining, it needs a chainsaw." An unnamed delegate, quoted by ENB.
