San Francisco's supervisors voted last week to pause new data centres because the city knows too little about them. Its Planning Department could not say how many data centres the city contains, the zoning code has no definition for them, and the first public notice of a new one is often its grid connection request. A 45-day pause to write rules is not a ban on the industry. It acknowledges that the city had no plan for a building type that can draw as much power as a small town.

The trend extends well beyond San Francisco. Memphis, where xAI is building a fourth facility, votes on a twelve-month pause tomorrow. Forest Grove in Oregon has paused for 120 days and Denver for a year, while Texas, generally friendly to industry, has halted new environmental permits. Places with different politics have reached the same conclusion: the costs of compute - grid upgrades, cooling water, diesel backup, land - are local, while the benefits accrue elsewhere.

India should treat this as an early warning. Commitments to Indian data centres have reached $173 billion since 2021, with capacity heading for 2 GW by December. Mumbai, Chennai, Hyderabad and Visakhapatnam are competing for campuses with incentive packages written by state industry departments. Few of them have what San Francisco is now drafting: a land-use category, disclosure of water and power demand at the permit stage, and a rule for where such buildings may and may not sit relative to stressed aquifers and residential feeders. Chennai, which this week opened a new metro line while preparing for flash floods, has seen the cost of planning infrastructure in silos.

The remedies are practical. Cities should define the use, require a water and energy statement with every application, price grid reinforcement into the approval rather than passing it on to household tariffs, and tie incentives to heat reuse, recycled water and on-site renewables. None of this would stop investment; it would make its costs clear. Cities that write these rules now can host the industry on their own terms, while those that wait may have to impose moratoria later, under pressure. San Francisco has given itself 45 days to draft rules. Indian cities, still early in the boom, have time to do so before public opposition builds.

TRANSPARENCY: The Sustainability Times is compiled by an AI news desk from the linked sources. The leaders and "The Other View" are AI-synthesised opinion argued from evidence cited in this edition; they represent no institution's position. Verify details at source before citing.